top of page

Blog

Thanksgiving and Food Anxiety: Navigating a Holiday Centered Around Eating

drg6809
7 minutes ago
8 min read


Thanksgiving dinner table: Thanksgiving table with seasonal dishes and autumn decorations.

When Thanksgiving Isn't Just About the Food

For many people, Thanksgiving brings to mind family gatherings, favorite dishes, and traditions centered around sharing a meal. For others, the holiday may look entirely different. Not everyone celebrates Thanksgiving, and family gatherings can bring up complicated emotions, cultural differences, or difficult memories.


When you struggle with food anxiety, disordered eating, or an eating disorder, a holiday centered around food can feel particularly overwhelming.

There is the anticipation of a large meal, the pressure of eating in front of others, and the possibility of relatives commenting on what or how much you are eating. Then there are familiar conversations about dieting, weight, and what everyone plans to do to "make up for" Thanksgiving dinner.


What is supposed to be a meaningful celebration can quickly become a source of anxiety, guilt, or distress. You deserve to participate in meaningful experiences without shame or pressure to justify your eating habits.


Why Thanksgiving Can Trigger Food Anxiety

Thanksgiving can introduce several situations that make food-related anxiety more noticeable. Understanding these triggers can help explain why the holiday feels so difficult.


Food-Related Expectations

Thanksgiving traditions often revolve around specific meals and expectations about eating. For someone experiencing food anxiety, changes to their usual routine can feel unpredictable. You might worry about what foods will be available, how meals are prepared, or whether you will feel comfortable eating around others.


Fear of Judgment

Eating in front of others can feel uncomfortable when you are already self-conscious about food. You might wonder whether relatives are watching your plate, noticing what you leave behind, or comparing your eating habits with theirs. Even seemingly harmless comments can reinforce these concerns.


Body Image Concerns

Family gatherings sometimes bring conversations about appearance, weight changes, or how people have changed since the last gathering. For someone experiencing body dissatisfaction, these conversations can increase self-consciousness and negative self-evaluation.


Family Dynamics

Food anxiety is not always about food itself. Family interactions can reactivate longstanding patterns involving control, criticism, comparison, or expectations. The stress of navigating these relationships can make existing eating disorder symptoms more difficult to manage.


Food Anxiety, Disordered Eating, and Eating Disorders: Understanding the Difference

Although these terms are sometimes used interchangeably, they describe different experiences.


What Is Food Anxiety?

Food anxiety describes distress, worry, or fear associated with eating, particular foods, or eating situations. Someone might worry about eating in public, trying unfamiliar foods, or experiencing uncomfortable physical sensations after eating. Food anxiety is not a diagnosis in itself.


Disordered eating refers to problematic attitudes or behaviors involving food, eating, or body image. These patterns can cause significant distress without necessarily meeting the diagnostic criteria for a specific eating disorder.


Examples include rigid food rules, persistent guilt surrounding meals, avoiding certain foods, or becoming preoccupied with eating habits.


Eating disorders are diagnosable mental health conditions involving disturbances in eating behaviors that can significantly affect psychological well-being, physical health, or daily functioning.


Common diagnoses include anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, binge-eating disorder, avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder (ARFID), and other specified feeding or eating disorder (OSFED).


Importantly, eating disorders do not always involve concerns about weight or appearance.


Individuals with ARFID, for example, may experience food-related difficulties associated with sensory sensitivities, fear of unpleasant physical consequences, or a lack of interest in eating.

Eating disorders can affect individuals of all ages, backgrounds, and body sizes. Food-related distress deserves attention even when someone does not meet the diagnostic criteria for an eating disorder.


How Diet Culture Makes Thanksgiving More Complicated

One of the more confusing aspects of Thanksgiving is the contradictory messaging surrounding food.


People are encouraged to enjoy holiday meals while simultaneously receiving messages about avoiding weight gain, exercising more, or returning to restrictive eating habits afterward.


Consider some comments that frequently come up during holiday gatherings:

  • "I'm being bad today."

  • "I'll have to work this off tomorrow."

  • "I'm saving all my calories for dinner."

  • "I shouldn't have eaten that."

  • "Are you really having seconds?"


Although these comments may seem harmless, they can reinforce the idea that food choices determine someone's worth or self-control. For someone in eating disorder recovery, these conversations may intensify existing fears or urges to engage in disordered behaviors.


Challenging All-or-Nothing Thinking

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) helps individuals recognize and challenge unhelpful thought patterns.


For example:


Unhelpful Thought: "If I eat something outside my usual routine, I've ruined everything."


More Balanced Perspective: "My eating habits do not need to be perfect. One meal does not define my health, progress, or worth."


Food does not have moral value. Enjoying a holiday meal does not require compensation, and eating differently on a particular day does not mean you have failed.


Navigating Thanksgiving While Supporting Eating Disorder Recovery

If you are working toward eating disorder recovery, Thanksgiving may require additional planning. The goal is not to eliminate every uncomfortable feeling but to approach the holiday in a way that supports your treatment.


1. Maintain Your Treatment Plan

Continue following your established nutritional and clinical recommendations. Avoid independently changing meal plans or eating patterns to accommodate the holiday. Skipping meals beforehand or restricting afterward can reinforce disordered behaviors.


Consider discussing anticipated challenges with your therapist or registered dietitian before Thanksgiving. They can help develop an individualized plan that accounts for your treatment needs.


2. Prepare for Potential Triggers

Think about which aspects of the holiday tend to increase your anxiety. Are certain conversations particularly difficult? Do you feel uncomfortable eating around specific relatives? Are changes to your usual routine especially stressful?

Identifying potential challenges ahead of time can help you determine what additional support might be helpful.


3. Identify a Supportive Person

Consider sharing your concerns with someone you trust. This might be a family member, partner, or friend who understands your recovery goals.


Let them know which situations might be difficult and what kind of support would feel helpful. For example, they might redirect conversations about dieting or check in with you if you become overwhelmed.


4. Practice Flexibility Without Abandoning Recovery Goals

Holidays often involve changes in schedules, routines, and social expectations. Learning to navigate these changes can be an important part of recovery.


However, flexibility does not mean abandoning the structure or support your treatment requires. Work with your treatment team to approach changes without compromising your recovery goals.


5. Use Coping Skills When Anxiety Increases

When food-related anxiety becomes overwhelming, strategies informed by Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) can help you respond to difficult emotions.


Consider the following:

  • Grounding: Bring your attention back to your surroundings when anxious thoughts become overwhelming.

  • Paced breathing: Slow your breathing to help manage physical symptoms of anxiety.

  • Thought identification: Recognize anxious thoughts without automatically accepting them as facts.

  • Mindfulness: Notice emotions without judging yourself or immediately reacting to them.


These strategies should support participation in meaningful experiences rather than become rituals used to neutralize food-related anxiety. You do not need to eliminate anxiety before engaging in recovery-supportive behaviors.


6. Focus on More Than the Meal

Thanksgiving does not have to revolve entirely around eating. Think about the people you enjoy spending time with, traditions that feel meaningful, or activities you look forward to.

You might watch a movie, play a game, or simply enjoy a conversation with someone you care about. The holiday can involve connection and shared experiences beyond food.


How to Respond to Comments About Food, Weight, and Appearance

Unfortunately, you cannot always control what other people say. However, preparing a few responses can help you protect your boundaries without turning every uncomfortable interaction into an argument.


When Someone Comments on Your Food

Comment: "Are you really going to eat all of that?"


Response: "I'd prefer not to discuss what's on my plate."


When Someone Talks About Dieting

Comment: "I'm going to have to be so good tomorrow."


Response: "I'm trying to avoid conversations about dieting. How has your week been?"


When Someone Comments on Your Body

Comment: "You look like you've lost weight!"


Response: "I'd rather not discuss my body, but it's good to see you."


When Someone Pressures You to Eat Differently

Comment: "Come on, you have to try this!"


Response: "Thanks for offering. I'd prefer not to discuss what I'm eating."

For individuals in eating disorder treatment, decisions about food should remain consistent with individualized treatment recommendations. Setting boundaries around unwanted comments is different from using boundaries to reinforce food avoidance or other eating disorder behaviors.


If someone continues making uncomfortable comments after you have expressed your preferences, you can briefly restate your boundary, redirect the conversation, or seek support from someone you trust.


You are not obligated to discuss your body, justify your food choices, or participate in conversations about dieting.


What to Do When Food Anxiety Continues After Thanksgiving

For some individuals, the anxiety does not end when the gathering is over.


You might experience guilt, increased body dissatisfaction, or persistent thoughts about what you ate. These feelings can trigger urges to restrict, overexercise, purge, or engage in other compensatory behaviors.


Rather than treating the following day as an opportunity to undo or make up for eating, return to your established eating routines and individualized treatment recommendations.


If urges to engage in disordered behaviors become stronger, reach out to your treatment team or a trusted support person.


A difficult meal or uncomfortable holiday experience does not erase your progress. Recovery is not defined by having a perfect day. It is about continuing to make choices that support your well-being, even when difficult emotions arise.


When to Seek Professional Support

If you experience persistent anxiety surrounding food, eating, body image, or social situations involving food, a professional evaluation may be beneficial.


Warning signs include increasing food restriction, binge eating, purging, compulsive exercise, rigid food rules, or avoiding social activities involving meals.


Eating disorders can affect individuals of all body sizes and may involve serious medical complications. You do not need to reach a particular weight or level of distress before seeking help.


Treatment may involve collaboration between mental health clinicians, medical providers, and registered dietitians. Depending on the individual's diagnosis, age, medical status, and treatment needs, evidence-based approaches may include Enhanced Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Eating Disorders (CBT-E), family-based treatment (FBT), and exposure-based interventions.


Early support can make a meaningful difference. You do not have to wait until symptoms become severe to ask for help.


Thanksgiving Is About More Than What's on Your Plate

Thanksgiving can be complicated when food, eating, or body image are sources of anxiety.

But the holiday does not have to be defined by what you eat, what others think about your plate, or whether you feel perfectly comfortable throughout the gathering.


You deserve to participate in meaningful experiences without shame or judgment.


Recovery is not about eliminating every uncomfortable feeling. It is about learning to respond to those feelings in ways that support your well-being.


Sometimes, that begins with recognizing that your worth has absolutely nothing to do with what is on your Thanksgiving plate.


How Upper East Side Psychology Can Help

At Upper East Side Psychology, our clinicians specialize in treating eating disorders, disordered eating, body image concerns, and related emotional difficulties.


Our clinicians draw from evidence-based eating disorder treatments, including Enhanced Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Eating Disorders (CBT-E), family-based treatment (FBT), and exposure-based interventions. We may also incorporate strategies from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) when clinically appropriate.


We help children, adolescents, and adults develop healthier relationships with food, their bodies, and themselves. Our clinicians work collaboratively with medical providers, registered dietitians, and families when appropriate to support comprehensive, individualized treatment.


We offer in-person therapy on the Upper East Side and in Midtown Manhattan, as well as virtual therapy throughout New York State.


Schedule a free 15-minute consultation to connect with a therapist who can help.

Comments


Meet the Therapists

Dr Gabrielle Schroyer-Hoffman, Phd
Dr. Schreyer-Hoffman, Ph.D.

Founder and Licensed Psychologist in NY, VA and PsyPact States

Dr. Kayla Yellen, Psy.D_
Dr. Kayla Yellen, Psy.D.

Clinical Psychologist, 

Director of Training and Supervision

Dr. James Modico, Psy.D.
Dr. James Modico, Psy.D.

Postdoctoral Fellow

​

Dr. Cierra Clark, PsyD
Dr. Cierra Clark Psy.D.

Postdoctoral Fellow

​

Dr. Linda Nisanova, Psy.D_
Dr. Linda Nisanova Psy.D.

Postdoctoral Fellow

​

Averey Esposito LMSW
Averey Esposito

LMSW

​

Kate Bollerman, MHC-LP_edited.jpg
Kate Bollerman

 MHC-LP

​

Danielle Minogue
Danielle Minogue

LMSW

​

Caitlin Frankel, LMSW_edited_edited.jpg
Caitlin Frankel

LMSW

​

Ella Williams LMSW
Ella Williams

LMSW

​

Maya Statmore, LMSW
Maya Statmore

LMSW

​

Paige Deertz. LMSW
Paige Deertz

LMSW

​

Read what our patients have to say about us.

“The entire staff operates with integrity, compassion, and a clear commitment to client well-being. Their collaborative and trauma-informed approach fosters a safe and supportive environment for meaningful therapeutic work.”

“

“Dr. G is a highly skilled and insightful clinician whose presence is both grounded and attuned. Her approach is thoughtful, evidence-informed, and deeply respectful of the therapeutic process.”

“

Upper East Side Psychology
Midtown East Psychology

Providing in-person and virtual therapy in New York and virtual therapy in Virginia and Psypact States.

Get in touch

Upper East Side

115 East 82nd Street

New York, NY 10028

​Midtown East

420 Lexington Avenue Suite 354

New York, NY 10170

Thanksgiving and Food Anxiety: Navigating a Holiday Centered Around Eating
Thanksgiving and Food Anxiety: Navigating a Holiday Centered Around Eating

When Thanksgiving Isn't Just About the Food For many people, Thanksgiving brings to mind family gatherings, favorite dishes, and traditions centered around sharing a meal. For others, the holiday may look entirely different. Not everyone celebrates Thanksgiving, and family gatherings can bring up complicated emotions, cultural differences, or difficult memories. When you struggle with food anxiety, disordered eating, or an eating disorder, a holiday centered around food can feel particularly...

Sweater Weather and Your Mental Health: Why Fall Feels Different
Sweater Weather and Your Mental Health: Why Fall Feels Different

Why Does Sweater Weather Feel Different? There's something about the first chilly day in New York City. Suddenly, everyone's wearing sweaters, ordering pumpkin spice lattes, and enjoying the changing leaves in Central Park. Summer afternoons outdoors give way to afternoons in cozy coffee shops, weekend beach trips turn into apple-picking outings, and seasonal menus return to our favorite restaurants. For some people, fall feels refreshing. It's an opportunity to slow down, establish routines,...

Therapy for Executives and Professionals: What Makes It Different?
Therapy for Executives and Professionals: What Makes It Different?

Introduction Being successful does not necessarily mean feeling well. Executives, physicians, attorneys, entrepreneurs, finance professionals, consultants, and other high-performing professionals are often expected to remain calm, decisive, and productive, even when the pressure is intense. When you're responsible for a team, a business, patients, clients, or significant financial decisions, there may be little room to admit that you're struggling. Over time, that pressure can contribute to...

Latest Blog Posts

Upper East Side Psychology® is a registered trademark.  © 2025 Upper East Side Psycholgy PLLC. All rights reserved.    |    Privacy  Policy   |    Terms

bottom of page