When Therapy Isn’t Working (Yet): What Stalls Progress and How to Get Unstuck

When Therapy Isn’t Working (Yet): What Stalls Progress and How to Get Unstuck

Starting therapy often comes with hope: relief, clarity, change. For many people, therapy does lead to meaningful improvement. But for others, there comes a quieter, more confusing moment—when sessions feel stagnant, progress slows, or the same patterns keep showing up despite effort.

If you’ve ever found yourself wondering, “Why isn’t therapy helping?” or “Am I doing something wrong?”—you’re not alone. Feeling stuck in therapy is more common than people realize, and it doesn’t mean therapy has failed. More often, it signals that something needs to shift.

Understanding why therapy sometimes stalls—and how to address it—can help you re-engage with the process and move forward more effectively.

First, What Does “Not Working” Actually Mean?

Therapy doesn’t follow a straight line. Progress often includes periods of insight, discomfort, plateaus, and growth. Feeling challenged or emotionally stirred does not mean therapy isn’t working.

However, therapy may feel “stuck” when:

1. Sessions feel repetitive without new insight

   
   

2. You understand your patterns intellectually but behavior hasn’t changed

   
   

3. You leave sessions unsure what you’re working toward

   
   

4. You avoid certain topics week after week

   
   

5. Emotional relief feels temporary or inconsistent

   
   

6. You feel disconnected from your therapist or the approach

   
   

Research suggests that perceived lack of progress is one of the most common reasons clients discontinue therapy prematurely.¹ Importantly, many of these situations are fixable.

Common Reasons Therapy Progress Stalls

1. Avoidance (Often Unintentional)

Avoidance is one of the most powerful forces in mental health—and one of the most subtle. Clients may unconsciously steer away from painful emotions, memories, or behaviors that feel threatening to explore.

Avoidance can look like:

1. Talking about feelings rather than experiencing them

   
   

2. Focusing on surface stressors instead of deeper themes

   
   

3. Using humor, intellect, or productivity to stay detached

   
   

4. Avoiding homework or between-session practice

   
   

Avoidance often protects in the short term, but research shows it maintains anxiety, depression, and trauma symptoms long-term.² Effective therapy gently identifies and works through avoidance rather than reinforcing it.

2. Misalignment Between Goals and Treatment Approach

Different problems require different therapeutic strategies. Insight-oriented work, skills-based therapy, trauma-focused approaches, or relational therapy each serve different purposes.

If therapy feels stalled, it may be because:

1. Goals aren’t clearly defined

   
   

2. The treatment approach doesn’t fully match the presenting problem

   
   

3. The pace is too fast—or too slow

   
   

Evidence-based care emphasizes treatment planning and flexibility.³ Therapy should evolve as your needs change.

3. Intellectual Insight Without Behavioral Change

Many high-functioning clients understand why they feel the way they do—but still feel stuck behaving differently.

Insight alone does not automatically lead to change. Research consistently shows that behavioral and experiential components are essential for lasting improvement.⁴

Therapy that incorporates:

1. Behavioral experiments

   
   

2. Skills practice

   
   

3. Emotional exposure

   
   

4. Between-session application

   
   

is often more effective than insight alone.

4. Fear of Change (Even Positive Change)

Change can feel destabilizing—even when it’s desired. Letting go of familiar patterns can bring up fear, grief, or uncertainty.

Clients may worry:

1. “Who am I without this coping strategy?”

   
   

2. “What if I disappoint people?”

   
   

3. “What if things change and I lose control?”

   
   

Ambivalence about change is normal and expected. Addressing it openly can unlock forward movement.

5. The Therapeutic Relationship Needs Attention

The relationship between client and therapist is one of the strongest predictors of successful outcomes.⁵ If something feels off—unspoken frustration, uncertainty, or lack of connection—it can slow progress.

Common relational barriers include:

1. Difficulty expressing dissatisfaction

   
   

2. Fear of hurting the therapist’s feelings

   
   

3. Misunderstandings about expectations

   
   

4. Cultural or communication mismatches

   
   

Open conversation about the therapy process itself often strengthens, rather than weakens, treatment.

How Evidence-Based Therapy Gets Unstuck

Feeling stuck doesn’t mean starting over—it means adjusting. Effective therapy adapts intentionally.

1. Re-Clarifying Goals

Therapy works best when goals are specific, collaborative, and revisited regularly. Clarifying what you want to feel, do, or experience differently creates momentum.

2. Shifting the Focus of Sessions

When progress stalls, therapists may shift toward:

1. More skills-based work

   
   

2. Greater focus on emotions in the moment

   
   

3. Behavioral change rather than analysis

   
   

4. Addressing avoidance directly

   
   

This recalibration is a sign of responsive, high-quality care.

3. Increasing Between-Session Practice

Change happens between sessions. Research shows that practicing skills outside of therapy significantly improves outcomes.⁶

This might include:

1. Thought-challenging exercises

   
   

2. Behavioral experiments

   
   

3. Exposure work

   
   

4. Boundary-setting practice

   
   

5. Emotion regulation tools

4. Naming the Stuckness Directly

One of the most powerful steps is simply saying, “I feel stuck.” Therapy is a collaborative process, and voicing this opens space for adjustment.

5. Assessing Fit Without Self-Blame

In some cases, a different approach—or a different therapist—may be appropriate. This is not a failure; it’s part of ethical, client-centered care.

When to Consider a Change

You might explore adjustments if:

1. You’ve been in therapy for a significant time with no clear direction

   
   

2. Goals haven’t been revisited

   
   

3. Avoidance remains unaddressed

   
   

4. You feel unable to be honest in sessions

   
   

5. You don’t understand the treatment plan

   
   

A thoughtful conversation about next steps is often the most productive first move.

How Upper East Side Psychology Approaches Stalled Progress

At Upper East Side Psychology, we believe transparency and collaboration are essential. Our clinicians use evidence-based approaches including CBT, ACT, DBT, trauma-informed care, and skills-based interventions to ensure therapy remains purposeful and responsive.

We regularly:

1. Revisit goals

   
   

2. Adjust pacing and focus

   
   

3. Integrate skills and experiential work

   
   

4. Address avoidance compassionately

   
   

5. Invite open dialogue about the therapy process

   
   

We offer both in-person therapy in NYC and virtual therapy across PSYPACT states, allowing flexibility as life evolves.

Final Thoughts

Feeling stuck in therapy doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong—or that therapy can’t help. Often, it’s a sign that something important is just beneath the surface, waiting to be addressed.

With the right adjustments, therapy can regain momentum and continue supporting meaningful, lasting change.

Book Your Consultation