What to Expect in Your First Therapy Session: A Guide for New Clients

Beginning therapy is a big step—and one that often comes with a mix of emotions. You might feel hopeful and relieved to finally get support. You might also feel nervous, uncertain, or even intimidated by the idea of opening up to someone new.

At Upper East Side Psychology, we believe that understanding what to expect can reduce anxiety and help you feel more in control as you begin the therapeutic process. This guide walks you through the first session and the broader intake experience, so you can take that first step with confidence.

Why Understanding the First Session Matters

Many therapy seekers delay getting help because they don’t know what to expect. They may ask:

1. “Will I have to talk about everything right away?”

2. “Will my therapist judge me?”

3. “Is it okay to feel awkward or unsure?”

   
   

The short answer: Yes, it’s normal to feel nervous. And no, you won’t be judged. A well-structured first session is designed to help you feel safe, supported, and understood—at your pace.

Before the Session: The Therapy Intake Process

At Upper East Side Psychology, your journey typically begins with a 15- to 20-minute intake call with a member of our team. This is not a clinical session but a chance to learn more about your needs and match you with the right therapist. We’ll ask questions such as:

1. What concerns or symptoms are you hoping to work on?

2. Are there specific types of therapy you’re interested in (e.g., CBT, DBT, trauma-focused)?

3. Do you prefer virtual or in-person sessions?

4. Are there particular days/times that work for your schedule?

   
   

Once matched, you’ll receive intake paperwork to complete before your first appointment. This includes basic demographics, consent forms, and brief questionnaires to give your therapist a starting point.

The First Session: Setting the Foundation

The first therapy session is often called the intake session or initial evaluation. Here’s what typically happens:

1. Warm Welcome and Orientation

Your therapist will begin by introducing themselves, explaining confidentiality, and setting the tone for a safe, collaborative relationship. They'll clarify:

1. The limits of confidentiality (e.g., safety concerns)

2. The structure and frequency of sessions

3. What therapy is (and isn’t)

   
   

You don’t need to prepare anything in advance. Just show up as you are.

2. Sharing Your Story (At Your Pace)

The first session is not about solving everything—it's about starting a relationship. You’ll be invited to talk about:

1. What brought you to therapy now

2. Past experiences with therapy (if any)

3. Current symptoms, stressors, or goals

4. Important parts of your history (family, medical, emotional)

   
   

You’re in control. If there’s something you’re not ready to share, that’s okay. Building trust takes time.

3. Exploring Goals and Hopes for Therapy

Your therapist will help you define what you hope to gain from therapy. Some clients arrive with clear goals (“I want to manage my panic attacks”), while others aren’t sure yet (“I just know I don’t feel like myself lately”). Both are equally valid.

Expect your therapist to ask questions like:

1. What would progress look like for you?

2. Are there specific changes you’d like to see in your daily life?

3. How would you know therapy is helping?

   
   

These early discussions help shape your treatment plan.

Common Feelings After the First Session

It’s normal to walk away from your first therapy session with a mix of emotions. Some people feel immediate relief. Others feel emotionally drained, uncertain, or even skeptical. That’s okay.

Therapy is not a one-time fix—it’s a process. Like any meaningful relationship, the therapeutic alliance takes time to build. We encourage clients to give it a few sessions before drawing conclusions.

How Therapy Works Over Time

While each therapist has a unique style, here are some common elements you can expect across ongoing sessions:

1. Active listening: Your therapist is not just a passive observer—they’re engaged, asking thoughtful questions and helping you explore patterns.

2. Skill-building: You may learn practical tools, like emotion regulation, cognitive reframing, or communication strategies.

3. Processing deeper issues: Over time, you may explore deeper emotional wounds, relational dynamics, or core beliefs that impact your present.

4. Measurable progress: Many clients track symptom relief, behavior change, or shifts in self-awareness over time.

   
   

Therapy can be short-term or long-term, depending on your goals.

FAQs About Starting Therapy

Do I need to know exactly what’s wrong to start therapy?

Not at all. Many people start therapy simply feeling “off” or overwhelmed. Therapy can help you figure things out.

What if I don’t connect with my therapist?

A good fit is essential. If something doesn’t feel right, bring it up. We can also help you find a different provider.

How soon will I feel better?

Some clients feel a shift after the first session, while others take a few weeks. The pace varies, but consistency is key.

Is virtual therapy as effective as in-person?

Yes. Research shows that virtual therapy can be just as effective as in-person sessions for most conditions (American Psychological Association, 2021).

Taking the First Step

If you’ve been thinking about starting therapy, now is a great time to take that next step. Whether you're dealing with anxiety, depression, stress, life transitions, or something you can’t yet name—therapy offers a space to be seen, heard, and supported.

At Upper East Side Psychology, we’re here to help you get started. From your first intake call to your first session and beyond, our goal is to make the process as comfortable and empowering as possible.

Ready to begin?

Fill out our contact form or schedule a consultation call. We're here to support you.

Book Your Consultation